I wish it was as simple as that T U T;;;
I’ve attempted this with 0mega and several other Alchemists back in CBT2, and while we agreed on listing our Potions for the same price, there will always be that one bastard Alchemist out there who just wants to watch the world burn…
||orz
Oh yeah, there could be a sort of majority rule here. The majority vote sets the prices, then the advantage/disadvantage thing comes into play. This is a coded-in mechanic, if that isn’t super clear. For instance, if a player is not a part of the “union”, their potions are weaker. Even if it’s by a small margin, nobody wants to buy weaker potions, and their effectiveness in influencing prices is more or less ruled out.
That’s why it’s such a far fetched suggestion though HAHA they’d have to implement a whole new, weird system and it severly restricts the class’s freedom in terms of individual choice. You’re more or less forced into the “union” and there’s virtually no difference between different alchemists as a result. Causes a lot of trouble for both devs and players in the name of making a single class unobselete.
It became impossible at the end of beta, as the Market was littered with potions nobody would buy. So the price just kept falling. Due to new rising Alchemists, and falling player-base.
The same will happen in OBT, eventually.
I for one welcome it. Hoping to get really cheap pots by the time I start playing in april 
The problem here is , when competition is way too high irl to make a profit people drop the job and become something different. The only way to drop your alchemist in ToS would be deleting it and noone in their right minds is going to do that. Better stuff that is a lot harder ( making it rarier) to make needs to be created and the mat for that shouldnt come through the alchemist itself. ToS should be a Web not a Flower.
Someone didn’t apply the offer/demand law from beginning to end 
But if we start on this slope…
Well we can’t realistically expect ToS to be a business simulator…
I know this is a shot in the dark but I was confused why pardoner and squire make money and alchemist doesn’t.
Isn’t it because they vend their services instead of putting them on the market?
So… wouldn’t it make sense just to have alchemist vendors selling different types of potions? At least this way they don’t suffer from tax. It’s not like Alchemist have a choice in being taxed.
Squires are now taxed, while they repair, so it makes litle difference using the market.
There is no way to directly control prices on market (setting minimum price or affecting it with taxes achieves nothing) as well there is no way to control demand.
As i see it it is possible to indirectly affect supply of those potions:
Remove crafting materials from alchemist NPC - those have to be gathered in field. Period. That would liven up market for crafting materials. Prices of crafted potions will fluctuate depending on reagent prices and alchemists will have to think about price for their time gathering those mats personally so undercutting on market will only devalue their own time.
Have crafting potions consume some SP per potion crafted and halt natural SP regen during crafting process. That would limit the amount of potions one can craft in one batch. Active alchemists will have advantage over AFK ones, also that would open opportunities for Kabbalists to be hired for their “Ein Sof” SP attribute for quick SP recovery.
You can’t vend potions the way you do with Gem Roasting / Squire’s Repair and Buff / Pardoner’s Scroll Shop. You just craft potions and they all go into your inventory. Plus, players are more likely to buy potions in bulk which would mean that it will take a longer time to craft, then that will have to be made to order.
So unless you’re willing to dedicate time spamming the Shout Chat for it and keeping your post near a warehouse, and unless you’re popular enough to have a crowd of Loyal Buyers, there’s no better or convenient way to sell potions but through the market.
edit my thoughts are all over the place, sorry for edits. haha~
Edited my Awakening/Blacksmith/Briquetting comparison post.
Please be clement with all my nonsense.
If you can’t cope with it (and my broken english), please jump to the conclusion.
Here lies my hopes and dreams of being an Alchemist… or a Squire for that matter.
Oblation would make more profit. Kek.
Does briquetting bonus scale with weapon enchantment (or rather does briquetting bonus apply before or after enchantment)?
Briquetting only applies to the weapon base. Enchantment has no effect.
Whats the issue with potions? Is it that there is 0 profit? How long and how much silver does it cost to make them?
Also, what do vendor prices have to do with anything, are they better than player made potions?
Yes.
Wait, isn’t briquetting +9.5 or -9.5 only? I though you can’t get anything in between.
So it’s not that bad for min maxing, you can get up to 40 attack from it.
But for sure it’s not a profitable skill, mainly fot 1 time offers.
Regarding item awakening, if you have +15 or so item with 4+ potential left, it’s reasonable to use briquetting/awakrning on it, as you nay fail an upgrade and get back to +10, so alchemist enhancements is the best way to upgrade it. Even if stats may be useless, it’s still better than nothing.
But again, not profitable.
If you fail an upgrade, you don’t go back to +10. (At least, you didn’t in iCBT2.)
I don’t think that briquetting works like you’re hoping it does : [Guide] Detailed Mechanics Overview
So again, unless my data is wrong, briquetting/awakening are worthless.
Ah, I see. Then it’s truly bad, but still better then awakening.
divine might doesn’t affect potion making. i reported it thinking it was a bug but i guess the devs made it intentional. lame.