I think this thread was made because there’s serious attitude problems on those threads and having different opinions or views on them are faced with pretty discouraging replies. So this thread was created with the opposite view being the “default” and roles of defenders and prosecutors are being reversed.
Last time I checked, those threads were full of whiny kids wanting everything being easy and no chances of doing mistakes in the game. (I mean this was their main motivator/reason behind wanting it, and the excuse/facade was possible class balancing ruining their build, instead of just balancing it.) It was rather discouraging to comment on them even if you thought many of the points were silly and you could easily give some good arguments for your “defense”. But why bother commenting on them when the attitude was like it was (I stopped following them so I don’t know if anyone bothered to give proper counter arguments for you)? These resets will very likely never happen so there’s not much of a point of wasting time trying to convince few kids and doomsday bringers.
It means this thread is just as pointless but it might encourage different tone in the conversation and bring out better arguments, now that the other side has come up with a solution/consensus you think is good(?).