Glad to hear they did it.
Guild wars should be a source lf entertainment not buttheart. Some people just create guilds for PvE and they don’t like PvP. Prevoius system caused too much trouble to uninterested players.
I’d rather prefer that they implemented Guild Wars Tournaments or something similar.
So that your guild can participate in it or not, and then it’d be able to declare the war to any participating guild(with certain restrictions) to score points. And in the end there should be some rewards for top guilds.
Also it might be possible to make some “divisions” like diamond golden and silver league so guilds from each league could only declare a war to guilds from the same league with separate ranking and rewards for each league.
This system will encourage people to participate in those events. Also guild members would be able to decide if they want to participate or not.
And there certainly should be some safe zones (like global market etc.) even during those war events or even light PvE only maps with lower rewards.
There are lots of ways how to make GvG fun for everyone and I think this was a first step to make it better.
Before it was simply dangerous to join guild and benefits were meaningless.
Also a good idea might be guild treasury where every member will be able to put money (but not take) and this money will be used for different GvG activities (like tower defense upgrades etc.). Also all upgrades would be lost if tower is destroyed so they shouldn’t be too strong/expensive.