That literally just shows how bad it is. You’re putting yourself in the best position possible(stationary Monster that doesn’t resist Zalcai), and can barely outdamage the Support variation with Priest(You forgot to add +150 dmg because of Blessing). You’re also comparing a skill that literally have really low str scaling(1hit), and not taking Knock Down attribute into account(+50% physical dmg); in the end, it’d look like :
(692+1091-200)(2)+(0.5 * 692)+150 = 3166 + 346 + 150 = 3662
(500+1091+61)(2) +(0.5 * 500) = 3304 + 250 = 3554
((692+1091-200)(1.5)+192)(2) + 346 + 150 = 5629
((500+1091+61)(1.5)+261)(2) + 250 = 5728.
I don’t feel like I need to talk about the damage with Conviction, since Conviction have better STR scaling and would end up outdamaging the spr variation no matter what. You also need to think about how much extra damage are you actually giving your teamates. How many extra crits did they do comparing to not having the buff? How many of them are physical damage dealers with DEX? If you want to go Krivis, choose the Bokor/Sadhu path, you’ll find no success with Paladin comparing to those 2.