Both of your builds are viable and it depends on which class you like more, Corsair or Doppelsoeldner.
On either build, I would pick up Barbarian C2/C3, as overall it is better for a Fencer build.
Although your first build could use Highlander's Cross Guard to
increase the Pierce damage of your Corsair's Hexen Dropper and Fencer's
Sept Etoiles, but it doesn't have that much synergy with Evasion builds,
if you were planning to follow a build like that.
Between Corsair and Doppelsoeldner, the first one has more burst
Pierce damage which is pretty good but it is limited by it's hitbox,
which isn't that big. On the other hand Doppelsoeldner has Cyclone which
is a better AoE skill but it doesn't offer the same burst as it
requires to channel it's full duration for it to be effective damage.
Deeds of Valor is slightly more difficult to stack up with an Evasion
build, but not impossible, so that is a nice bonus to have which will
have good synergy with your War Cry and Frenzy, both which will have the
attributes to improve them that you acquire from Barbarian C3.
Finally, there is the utility factor between Jolly Roger and Double
Pay Earn. Both of them will give you extra rewards on their own way, but
Double Pay Earn can give you extra EXP if you use it correctly
(especially during missions). While Corsair will keep on giving you
extra silver and from time to time items through the entire time you use
that character and it is also a small aggro tool that comes in handy
during certain situations.
I would say that currently, the Doppelsoeldner build has the
potential to deal more damage but it is conditional on the factor that
you can use the full duration of Cyclone, as well as being able to
properly stack Frenzy/Deeds of Valor/War Cry.
On the other hand, the Corsair build has more potential in the current
state of PvP in the game, thanks to Iron Hook. So if you are
interested on that aspect too, that could be another factor to consider.
And you are not going to be that far behind in damage with Corsair,
as you will still have Hexen Dropper on your build. While it is not as
high as the other build, it is more reliable as you don't depend on that
many variables to maximize your damage output. Which again, could be
better for situations like PvP.
Both paths sound pretty appealing and maybe I made this more
difficult for you, but with this you could have a better idea of what to
expect from each path.
Wow. Wasn’t expecting such dedicated and developed answer, that was extremely helpful, thanks!
Now, I went for Barb and my last doubt lies on whether going for C3 Barb or starting Corsair to reach C2 and later Fencer.
You posted you had a char with Barb C3 and then Fencer instead of Corsair C2 and then Fencer, and I have found that it’s the most common way to go too.
So I’m wondering: Is this for the fact that you have to wait until rank 7 to get to Fencer? Or the Barb C3 and the Corsair C2 benefits even out and none is “better” than the other one?
I hope my question is clear and it would be great if you could give me some insights in this matter.
Cheers!
PD: This is actually the first time I’m posting something so I was not sure how to quote your reply nicely like you addressed mine