Tree of Savior Forum

Concerning Valentines Contest Results - Traced Art?

Ok but I didnt ask your opinion

2 Likes

You got it either way, like no one asked you about insinuating anything about Elins art. Dont start attacking someone when u cant live with a something coming back at you.

And never ever start attacking someone I care about cause I dont have a problem with handing you back what ever you dish out.

1 Like

You seem mad

Ok, the problem is, actually I’m hurt, like the rest of the community that my drawing won’t show up on the loading screen, they could just choose everyone as honorable mentions because there’s an “effort” there and ToS is not really a huge community, also I never said that I’m a professional artist, there are flaws I know, and I’m trying to improve, but even the pink sprinkles are the same with your beloved friends work, but don’t act like she’s so very creative and I’m “NOT” obviously this is the same idea somehow. I’m not attacking and you’re the one who keeps attacking me and my style. Oh and don’t ever threaten me like that, you can’t hurt me like that through internet.

2 Likes

You asked for opinion by posting your works here. But you asked for another opinion.

Like: “Omahgawd, your works are totally better. You should’ve won! And Erin’s works are probably traced too!”.

Another friend I guess

@lollirot@Kaylee the winners were chosen randomly out of a pool of nominees. It was sort of a random process from the beginning. Your two works were great, one won out of luck, so lets not get at each others throats

3 Likes

Sorry but Kaylee is completely in the right here. These are two different drawings, with plenty of differing details. Just because they’re both chocolate boxes doesn’t mean one “copied” the other.

Personally, I quite like the winning chocolate box drawing. I thought it had a lot of cute little touches, like how the Hanaming chocolates are actually chocolate covered strawberries, the varied decorations on top of them, one of the chocolates sitting outside the box, the depth and detail of the box itself and where the chocolates slot into it, and so forth. It looks like a real box of fancy chocolates to me.

Yours is a much plainer box of chocolates featuring figures of various monsters rather than just Hanamings. They all appear to be solid chocolate with a few sprinkles here and there, in a plain box with very little detail added to it. Regardless of how well it’s drawn, it lacks the amount of detail that was put into the other one, which is probably why it was picked over yours.

2 Likes

Yeah, you are good at personal attacks. I got it already.

Keep your salt in yourself.

You guys are still criticizing, I never said my work is better than hers.

edit: [quote=“atari, post:30, topic:348482”]
Keep your salt in yourself.
[/quote]

I quit and I don’t care about this bs at all, no need to bring your whole guild here to bash on me

1 Like

You attacked the other artist first by implying they copied you and didn’t deserve the win.

You should probably just quit now before that hole gets any deeper, yeah.

3 Likes

By “quit” I mean I don’t give a ■■■■, not like you win the argument, but if that will make you any better, have a roleplay tea party on discord and brag about how you bashed on my work.

Peace.

1 Like

You assumed it.

And that another wotk was traced.


So, all people who think that your post was a groundless assumption or that your work is worse are in the same guild? Or maybe anyone who dare to disagree with you?

That’s another assumption.


Please make more posts to better show how much you don’t care.

Never knew atari was in my guild :smile:

@lollirot I never attacked you I criticised you, huge difference. i said that it maybe your style and I prefer different things and yeah, if it makes you feel better, I’m a bad person, I live from bashing other people to ake my puny reallife self feel better.

Happy now?

1 Like

I said your drawing was more plain at worst, which is an objective fact. That’s not bashing. Bashing is saying something like “this drawing sucks and I hate x y and z about it” with no suggestions for improvement or acknowledgement of the positive qualities. No one in this thread has bashed your art.

If you’re going to take offense to me saying such horrible, hateful things like “your box of chocolates was a bit more plain”, or Kaylee’s ghastly comment of “your box is cute but I didn’t like this part and the colouring could use improvement”, you probably shouldn’t enter contests like these where criticism is an inevitability.

2 Likes

I never entered a drawing :smiley:

I started one but then was consumed by a huge real life project so I didnt had the time to finish lollirot talked about the drawing of a guildmember.

yea my bad lol. i mispoke. still though, random pick x x

!!NOT PLAGIARISM!!

2 Likes

Hm… You should admit that you copied from someone’s work… At least its not worst than denying.

1 Like

Exactly. It’s quite common to people use something as base.







6 Likes

Using references is common also this is the perfect time for some DIO!

9 Likes