I agree with some of your points but not with all of them.
I want rodelero as mainly PvE tank/dd for my premade party, not PvP. And yet, while using slithering together with bloodletting you are totally immune to magic damage AND CC, so it has it’s uses (only speed is a problem but I’ve heard you can sprint while slithering, and you won’t be able to compete with mounted enemies damage).
Not sure how high kick works(I bet it just doubles strike damage like other empovering skills, otherwise C3 not worth it), but peltastas armor break is shield push and it’s 230 armor break for (7?) seconds, sure it’s not great but enough against most PvE monsters.
Slithering I will use against magic monsters insted of block after swashbuckling. Also targe smash deals double damage on frozen, and I will be in a party with cryo.
Talking about PvP, they improved Cataphracts animations so I hope Rodelero will be next.
Sure I know it will most probably feel weaker then Highlander in pair with Fencer, but it just fits the playstyle I want to implement with my fencer better. And I’m relying on future buffs when pick it.
So talking about your final conclusion I hope to deal good damage utilizing all those increase damage effects and proper armor types, I have enough tankability from Pelt C2, slitskills and fencer, lots of utility from skills and possibly even great PvP potential in future (IF they intended it to be a PvP class and will buff it’s PvP power).
Yet as I said I might drop it if it won’t have any synergy with R8 classes nor Fencer C3. I just feel like peltasta C1 is not enough for party tank (but great for solo/PvP) and it brings me a better utility then Highlander C2 for several reasons.
Going Peltasta C2 Highlander C3 Fencer C1 is also a possible way, so depending on new released classes/balance changes I might pick High C3 Fencer C1 R8, Rod C3 Fencer C1 R8 or Rod C2 Fencer C3 as my tank.
I will raise my High/Barb(not decided yet) as solo character anyway, so I will be able to swap it for tank midway if needed. That’s why I plan to start with Pel Rod. Just want to give him a chance and try personally if it’s as bad as people say.