While I agree that Black Desert is interesting, with tons of features and things to do, I was just bored for the entire beta weekend. The graphical engine is impressive yet the art is uninspired and boring. The entire world, from what I saw, was very bland. The character creation at first glance is very impressive, but it is also extremely limiting. The character creation tools in BnS are far more impressive, and allow for a far greater sense of freedom.
I found Black Desert to be very akin to Eve Online. Tons and tons of systems to allow it’s players to do as they please, but a lot of those systems feel like going to work. There is no immediate satisfaction while playing the game. Everything takes such a long time to do that you get bored halfway through. Lets chop that tree! Sixteen seconds later your character laboriously finishes the last swing of the axe. Whelp, guess I’ve had enough tree chopping.
There were moments while playing that I had a good time, but the tedium in between those moments was overpowering. I feel that BDO will have it’s niche audiance just as Eve does, but just like Eve before it, it just isn’t for me.
I think it’s the overall aesthetic of ToS that draws me in. I love the psuedo 2D art, the character design, the music. I fell in love with the class system before I ever tried the game. I honestly didn’t mind the grind one bit as even the humdrum was interesting in ToS due to it looking and playing so damn brilliant.