dear dev and players this is my opinion … its good u make a premium item/membership like a Token … but it makes some player hard / incovenience to play this game… you makes silver non-tradeable, even using Token …that-s really frustating them who farm silver whole game … and then, they using bot rather than they wasting time for only grind, or silver farm…
now, compare with the game with trade-able silver, when the gold-sellers, sell game currency to other players, they might be use their money for buy Premium item, like Token…and they who buy the silver, or we can say that Cash Player, will keep buy ur premium item …
i don’t say to makes RMT is legal…but just prevent and keep watching … don’t kill whole game just with a single decision …
not all Gold-seller just looking for money, they just want extra benefit, while playing a game like a cash-player…
you should change benefit of Token /Premium membership…
for example, like Tera Online, extra dungeon limit, extra auction limit, extra exp, Premium Mount for limited duration. etc
i think that’s better…
and they who is using cash for premium item, in-game currency, will avoid / stop boting for prevent ban ID. that’s i mean…
you guys just focus on BOT kill… RMT doesnt really will makes your game broken…instead makes your game is getting crowded…especially for international server… takes example ,DN, Tera, WoW…
this just my opinion … no offense… thanks 