Going into PVP as a cleric and not having oracle is a mistake. At least fit 1 circle of oracle into any PVP build.
Prophecy and Counter Spell are the 2 best skills for cleric pvp. Bloodletting used to be better but the duration got the axe. Prophecy only falls short if you dealing with multiple catagoons.
In fact, I would go cleric2 -> priest2 -> monk2 -> oracle -> Inquis to tinker with your 2nd build.
Your 1st build lacks cleric2, and honestly that is too good for pvp. You could just replace chaplain with cleric2 and then it is pretty solid, albeit a huge pain to level.
Cleric2 is important for 4 reasons.
-More heal tiles for added heals and potential damage. You can drop them near a dead player and they will kill in case they get resu’d.
-Cure damage is respectable with the attribute and more ranks in it. Can also lay on a dead target in case they get resu’d.
-Safety Zone attribute is a game changer for the skill.
-You want at least 1 point in Divine Might for 1 sec Resu Cast.