twohanded sword
or
twohanded spear
or
twohanded sword
or
twohanded spear
or
1st and 3rd one.
my reason is because better DPS.
many people think restrain is good, but in actual it is not. even you can use cyclone skill without restrain, it is already enough to kill anyone deadly at PVP (hard to be countered).
Okay then, let’s start with the first one.
Squire C1 won’t do you any good. Pick Corsair or Swordsman C2 or Pelta C1 for PvE.
The second is the same as above, albeit you picked up correct skills for Sword in PvP.
Third one is extremely well-crafted, well done.
Fourth is too spread out. Sword C2 is bad unless it’s PvP. Cata really shines only on C3. And Hop C3 also has Spear Throw.
Suggestion - 1 and 3. Pick Corsair instead of Squire for PvP and Pelta for PvE.