While im not really familiar with the term toxic. For me, the term toxic for this forum implies spreading hate, misinformation, pretty much posts that just do more harm than good, whether intentional or not.
While you say your asking nicely people see
Title: “desperation to play”
opening question: implies people are in agony while playing
Post content: bunch of issues that you are making seem worse than they are. Many arent even an issues. Dead server? f2p in 4 days. Balance? what game has balance on release? Server issues? these can be fixed. Dunegeon leecher? i have never seen this, so it much be rare.
ending question: Implying people have to force themselves to play because its that bad.
So, intentional or not, all this thread does is turn off potential new players. For no reason really. So, i could consider it toxic. Or whatever term you want to put to it.