Tree of Savior Forum

Crit Atk or Physical Atk?

Class and Rank Swordsman
#1

Hey guys,

Last night i was enchanting some Hair Costume and i got 2 situations. I got one with Physical Attack+ and one with Critical Attack+. I’m a Hoplite and i will invest in some equip and gems with critical chance+finestra to have some Critical from time to time.
And now i have a question, whats is the better option, Phy Atk+ or Crit Atk+ ???
I know that Critical damage come from a % of my Phy Attack, but depending on the formula of the damage Phy Atk may be a better option.
What do you guys think? Does anyone know this two formulas? For Physical Damage and Critical Damage?

Thanks ^^

#2

P.atk has priority since it’s always available plus it gets amplified by skills. C.atk requires a crit, which happens far less often after the big patch, and it doesn’t get amplified by skills.

#3

Not to mention that crit rate its nerfed

#4

Not true. I suggest you read up before you give out information yourself.

P.atk > c.atk because p.atk helps to break thru def. The multiplier is min{1,(log(atk/(def+1))^0.8) +1}. Long story short, the bigger atk is compared to def, the closer the multiplier gets to 1. C.atk does nothing for the multiplier.

So you can have really high c.atk, but a really low multiplier due to low atk.

In my case my SR on full STR can crit for 13k, but when changed to full DEX the crit is only 11k even though I have way higher c.atk.

#5

I test full dex build, and my crit attack is 1500+, but the crit damage is significantly lower than my crit attack. How can this be? (I tested it with lower level weapons and no weapons at all, )

#6

did you also remember the dmg you do with non critical damage with a full str and full dex , i wanna know

#7

I suggest you read again? You basically said the same thing I did…

#8

You said c.atk does not get amplified by skills. That means skill factor and c.atk DOES get amplified by it.